Mother’s Day isn’t about grand gestures, it’s about the little things that show just how much you care. And what’s more personal than a warm, freshly baked cookie made just for her?
My Better Batch makes it easy to whip up a sweet surprise Mom will love. With just one box of mix, some butter, and an egg, you can create cookies that taste better than homemade - no stress, no mess.
This year, we’re sharing four Mother’s Day-ready cookie recipes that start with our easy mixes and turn into something unique. They’re quick, customizable, and full of love - perfect for kids, dads, or anyone looking to say “thanks for everything” in the sweetest way possible.
Let’s get baking.
Four Cookie Recipes Moms Will Love
Each of these recipes starts with a My Better Batch cookie mix and turns into something warm, sweet, and extra special, just like Mom. Whether you’re baking with the kids or surprising her with a treat that tastes like you spent hours (spoiler: you didn’t), these ideas are simple to make and packed with love.
Here’s what we’re baking:
Sugar Cookie Cups with Reese’s
Soft sugar cookie cups filled with creamy peanut butter cups - sweet, salty, and totally irresistible.
Chocolate Chunk Cookies Rolled in Mini M&M’s
Classic, chewy, and bursting with color and crunch. Perfect for the mom who loves a playful twist.
Double Chocolate Cookies with Hershey’s Hugs & Kisses
Deep, fudgy chocolate meets melty kisses for the ultimate “I love you” in cookie form.
Chocolate Toffee Cookie Bars (with Crushed Heath Bar)
A little crispy, a little gooey, and a lot delicious - this is Mom’s favorite candy in bar-cookie form.
Each one only takes a few simple steps to make, and the results are impressive enough to feel bakery-worthy. Tap the links to get the full how-to for each recipe, and don’t forget to grab your favorite My Better Batch mix to get started!
Turn Simple Mixes into Unforgettable Moments
Baking for Mom doesn’t have to be complicated to be meaningful! Here’s why using My Better Batch cookie mixes as your foundation is a great choice:
Customize with Love
Every mom has that one favorite candy she can’t resist, or a flavor combo that instantly makes her smile. With My Better Batch, it’s easy to turn that into a one-of-a-kind cookie made just for her.
Our mixes are like a blank canvas - perfect for folding in chopped candy bars, rolling the dough in mini treats, or filling cookie cups with something gooey and sweet. Want to add caramel? Crushed peppermint? Her favorite chocolate? Go for it. The beauty is in the customization, and the love is in the details.
Over-the-Top, Under-the-Time
Let’s be real: Moms deserve something amazing, but that doesn’t mean you need to spend hours baking from scratch. With My Better Batch, you get cookies that look and taste over-the-top, with none of the stress.
Our mixes do the heavy lifting. All you have to do is stir in a few ingredients, pop them in the oven, and boom: bakery-level cookies in under 30 minutes.
So, whether you’re a baking newbie or a last-minute gift giver, this is your chance to impress without the mess. Dads, kids - yes, you can do this!
Sweet Memories, Made Simple & Stress-Free
Mother’s Day is about creating moments that matter. And sometimes, the best memories are made in the kitchen, laughing over cookie dough, sneaking chocolate chips, or surprising Mom with a warm batch fresh from the oven.
My Better Batch makes it easy to enjoy those moments without worrying about complicated recipes or long prep times. Just one bowl, a few simple steps, and cookies that taste better than homemade.
It’s baking made simple, so you can focus on what really counts: making her feel loved.
Moms Deserve the Sweetest Batch
At the end of the day, it’s not about perfection, it’s about the thought, the effort, and the love baked into every bite. Whether you're rolling dough in mini M&M’s or filling cookie cups with peanut butter, these little gestures mean everything.
So grab a box (or two!) of My Better Batch, choose a recipe that feels like “Mom,” and create something warm, sweet, and straight from the heart.
Shop our cookie mixes now and make this Mother’s Day one to remember - filled with love and a Better Batch.
